Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant

Discover authentic Italian flavors at Pizza Garden in New Oxford, PA. Enjoy delicious subs, cheese steaks, strombolis, and more at our welcoming restaurant. Call +1 717-624-7965 today!

Welcome to Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant

Taste the Difference.

Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant
Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant
Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant
Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant

Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant serves up delicious, authentic Italian cuisine in a cozy setting. Located at 105 Lincoln Way E, New Oxford, PA, this neighborhood gem specializes in classic Italian dishes that cater to every palate. Patrons rave about the subs and pizzas, and the rich flavors keep customers returning for more. With a festive atmosphere and friendly staff, it’s a perfect dining spot for families, friends, or a casual date night. Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty meatball sub or a delicious pasta dish, Pizza Garden has something for everyone.

On Friday nights, the restaurant fills up quickly, transforming into a bustling hub for locals craving good food.

The decor is homey, with touches of Italian charm that make the space feel inviting. If you’re looking for a meal that feels like a warm hug, this is the place to be.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

105 Lincoln Way E, New Oxford, PA 17350, United States

Phone

+1 717-624-7965

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant
Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant
Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant
Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant

Nestled in New Oxford, Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant stands out as a beloved local eatery. The restaurant’s commitment to quality ingredients shines in every dish, establishing a loyal customer base. Locals often recommend their famous Italian subs, showcasing juicy meats and fresh toppings layered within a soft roll. From chicken parmigiana to mouth-watering meatballs, Pizza Garden excels in crafting hearty Italian staples beloved by the community.

The restaurant thrives during busy times, especially on Fridays at 5 PM, when it reaches full capacity.

This popularity underscores its status as a go-to for families and friends looking to enjoy a meal together. On weekends, patrons indulge in savory pasta dishes such as spaghetti with meat sauce or sausage, beloved comfort foods that feel like home. The menu also caters to small appetites, allowing diners to share or sample multiple dishes comfortably.

An important aspect of Pizza Garden is its dedication to community. It frequently supports local events, giving back while delighting customers with delicious meals.

The inviting atmosphere, marked by friendly staff and cheerful décor, makes every visit enjoyable. It serves not just as a place to eat but as a gathering spot, strengthening community ties—much like the renowned Italian kitchens of old. Come hungry and enjoy the flavors, where every dish is crafted with love and tradition.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday11 AM-6:30 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday11 AM-7 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-7 PM
  • Friday11 AM-7 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-7 PM

Pizza Garden offers a diverse menu featuring over 67 dishes, ensuring that every visit is a new experience. From their famed cheese steaks and flavorful strombolis to a variety of subs, the offerings cater to every taste preference. The restaurant organizes its menu into categories: Dinners, Small Appetites, Combo Meals, and a vast selection of subs, both cold and hot. This structure makes it easy to find something to satisfy any appetite.

For those looking to enjoy a meal with family or friends, the combo meals provide great value. Enjoy a slice of pizza with tasty French fries, or try the half sub paired with a side.

The beverage selection adds to the variety, with options like Coca-Cola and Sprite complementing your meal perfectly. Each dish boasts fresh ingredients, and the portion sizes leave you feeling satisfied every time. Here, dining becomes an experience, not just a meal.

Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant

The exterior of Pizza Garden Italian Restaurant exudes charm and warmth, a welcoming sight for hungry patrons. Its quaint facade and inviting signage capture the essence of an Italian trattoria. Outdoor seating caters to those who want to enjoy their meals al fresco, making it a perfect spot to savor a sunny day or a cool evening.

The vibe here feels like a blend of excitement and relaxation.

Regulars share laughs as they wait for their food; new visitors automatically feel welcomed by the friendly atmosphere. The lively sounds of clanking dishes and sizzling pizzas create an environment bursting with energy, making every dining experience memorable.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Finally, a really good pizza! I heard this place is "meh" from one person. And "the best" from another. I like trying new pizza spots, and I gave this a shot. From the outside, you wouldn't think it was great. On a bumpy route 30, I wouldn't want to try and find a place to park if I was just passing through. But this is a hidden gem. A diamond across from a jewelry store. This pizza was near perfect. White mozzarella. It's not that yellow greasy color I've been having at other places. The crust was even great. Like a gourmet bread. And only $2 per topping! Inside was neat and clean. Waitress was awesome and attentive.

R
Robert E.

Great service, clean place, the food is super delicious!!! I recommend to go to this place!!

H
Heydi G.

We enjoyed a lovely lunch here after a busy day of shopping at the local antique shops. My wife and I enjoyed our Cheese Steaks, mine was a Cheese Steak Hoagie that was just great . Our waitress was wonderful as were the cooks here. They make their own bread!

K
Kenneth

A definite great place to grab a bite. Delicious food. Clean, comfort environment. Super staff. Welcomed my Service Dog (not companion...real Service Dog). Will be coming here often.

T
Ty

This is not your normal pizzeria. As you walk in, you can feel the friendly atmosphere, everybody is welcoming, there are smiles on everyone's faces. It's right off the main road so it's easily accessible. It's also handicap friendly. There was Italian news on the TV and the gentlemen who helped me order and who made my food was really friendly. He made me a handful of grilled chicken for my dog and I got the super Italian sub-cold. All the way minus onions. To the owner, I'm sorry I didn't catch your name but grazie! So che la mia visita e stata breve, ma mi e piaciuta la buona compagnia.

l
lindsay h.

the food here is always good when i come here and the service is always great and friendly they let me play my music whenever i do show up i've been going here since i was born the only bad thing i can say is that they're closed monday and tuesday but that's about it

E
Elvis P.